"Loud in the best way, and built for flip-flops, boat shoes and one more round at sunset." That is how Lew Bennett and Michael Landsberg of Tidewater Hospitality Group describe Castaways, according to Gulfshore Business. Castaways opened Sept. 14 in the space Harpoon Harry's filled for more than three decades. Upstairs from Castaways, in the old Captain's Table room, the same group opened Latitude 26° on June 29. Its entrees run from about $20 to $70.
Longtime Punta Gorda diners will recognize that layout, with a dressier room on the second floor and a casual bar on the deck below. Ron Evans and Harry Carson set it up in 1993, when they opened Harpoon Harry's and turned Earl Nightingale's upstairs into the Captain's Table. The 2026 rebuild kept that arrangement at the end of the wharf. It added a dock-to-table fish house and an island-style kitchen with sushi elsewhere in the complex, so Fishermen's Village now runs from a sub-$15 lunch to a tableside Wagyu tomahawk. This fall is the first season with all of it open at once.
How the end of the wharf turned over
The change started with a lease, not a hurricane. Harpoon Harry's and the Captain's Table served their last meals on Memorial Day 2025, May 26. Evans, who represented both restaurants through Smuggler's Enterprises, said two years of negotiation with the property had not produced a deal. WINK News also reported the closure as a lease issue, adding that both restaurants had renovated after Hurricanes Helene and Milton. Evans put their time at the Village at 45 years and 5 months.
Tidewater rebuilt both rooms. Dave Beers, the group's chief operating officer, said each space was gutted and rebuilt with new plumbing, new electrical systems and new layouts. Each restaurant covers about 12,000 square feet, which Beers compared to "approximately two Olive Gardens." Castaways alone needs six managers and a staff of about 150.
Before the rebuild, the Village had lost some of its draw. The Charlotte Sun wrote that hurricanes and closures had sent business downtown. By early February the property reported its retail and restaurant space 100% leased. All this leasing happened while a court-appointed receiver was managing the complex and marketing it for sale. The marina's reconstruction plans had been submitted to the governing agencies for approval.
Which room fits which night
The four new restaurants differ more in what kind of evening they suit than in what they serve, since all of them lean on seafood and the harbor view.
| Restaurant | Opened | Space it took over | Price signal | Hours |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Islands Kitchen & Cocktail House | Feb. 5 | The Pier | Wagyu tomahawk carved for four | Lunch and dinner daily |
| Latitude 26° | June 29 | Captain's Table, second floor | Entrees about $20 to $70 | 11 a.m. to 9 p.m., 10 p.m. Fri and Sat |
| Leroy's Fish Shack | Sept. 1 | Storm-damaged space, two years in the making | Catch of the day | 11 a.m. to 10 p.m., 11 p.m. Fri and Sat |
| Castaways | Sept. 14 | Harpoon Harry's, ground floor | Top item $32 | 10:30 a.m. to 9:30 p.m., 10:30 p.m. Fri and Sat |
For an anniversary or out-of-town family, Latitude 26° is the obvious pick. You reach the second-floor room by stairs or a private elevator. It has floor-to-ceiling windows over Charlotte Harbor and a patio that runs the length of the building, and the menu centers on hand-cut steaks, prime rib, seafood such as Chilean sea bass, and a long wine list. The bar faces an interior wall, so a large monitor there shows a live feed from cameras mounted outside. The second floor also gives sunset views from standard, high-top and outdoor seats.
For a weekday lunch that runs long, Castaways sits directly below. It seats 430, and its central bar has 180-degree water views. Many menu items cost under $15 or $20. Options include a Caribbean Mahi Wrap, Island BBQ Pulled Pork with pineapple, and Tacos from the Sea. The signature cocktail is the Shipwreck, a frozen daiquiri made with Bacardí Mango Chile rum. Joyce Beers, Tidewater's hospitality operations director, worked on the interiors of both rooms. Castaways got Key West-style colors and murals of Punta Gorda and the surrounding area.
For fish that was swimming a day or two ago, Leroy's Fish Shack is the newest arrival. Lee Richardson already runs Leroy's Southern Kitchen & Bar downtown, and he opened the Fish Shack with Capt. Mike Wright after more than two years of setbacks, several of them tied to Hurricane Milton. Fish arrives at the dock and is unloaded outside the dining room. The owners thanked Pine Island Seafood Company in Matlacha, formerly Barnhill Seafood Market, for their catch. Depending on the day, that could be grouper, snapper, hogfish, flounder, wahoo, Gulf shrimp or crab. The menu also carries the Yates Burger, a tribute to the late Chef Shannon Yates. The room has knotty pine walls, fishermen's nets and trophy mounts. Richardson ties it to the Punta Gorda Fish Company, where commercial fishermen once brought in their catch from the fish shacks in Bull Bay. To call ahead, the number is 941-397-5005.
For sushi or a big group, The Islands was the first of the four to open. It has the Village's only sushi, a menu its chef describes as an island approach to very fresh seafood, and a 32-ounce dry-aged Wagyu tomahawk carved tableside for four. The ownership team includes Amber and Dan DeCarlo of Punta Gorda, who also own Village Outfitters and Harborwalk Resort Wear, and Executive Chef Partner David McCleery of Port Charlotte. The Islands reopened Feb. 5 to lines out the door and hour-long waits.
Several longer-standing spots fill in around the new four. The Village's dining directory still lists Village Brewhouse, its outdoor bar at Center Court, and Sunset Beach Club. The shops changed too. Bee & Co., a cosmetics shop, opened across from The Islands, and Asthetik spa & skincare added a second location while keeping its downtown salon.
Where the music went
The biggest change for anyone who went to Harpoon Harry's for a band is physical. Castaways replaced the old indoor dance floor and band area with tables. An entertainment area is planned for the outdoor deck, and cameras will stream performers to screens throughout the restaurant.
For now, the Village's dependable live music is outside. The Punta Gorda Chamber lists free music every Friday and Saturday from 5 to 9 p.m. in Center Court and on the dry beach. Pair that with a table at Castaways or the patio at Latitude 26°, and a weekend evening at the Village is close to what it used to be, just spread across more of the property than one dance floor.
The calendar that fills those rooms
The rebuild lines up with Fishermen's Village's busiest stretch of the year. Here is what's on the books through New Year's Eve at 1200 W. Retta Esplanade, along with a few nearby events at Laishley Park:
- Oct. 3: German American Oktoberfest, noon to 8 p.m., with free admission and parking.
- Oct. 10: International Culture Fest, noon to 6 p.m., free.
- Oct. 11: LLSN Fall Arts & Crafts Fair at Laishley Park, 10 a.m. to 3 p.m., with food and craft vendors and costume contests.
- Oct. 17: The city's free Fall Festival at Laishley Park, noon to 4 p.m.
- Nov. 14: Lighting of the Village, 5 to 9 p.m., free.
- Nov. 15 through Dec. 31: The Holiday Festival of Lights runs daily, with free admission and parking.
- Dec. 1 through Dec. 31: King Fisher Fleet runs Christmas Light Canal Cruises nightly from the Village. There are no tours on Dec. 25, and fares vary.
- Dec. 20: A Christian Holiday Concert appears on the Village's events page.
- Dec. 31: New Year's Eve Celebration and Fireworks, 6 p.m. to 12:30 a.m., with free admission and parking.
The canal cruises fit naturally with dinner, since King Fisher Fleet operates out of Fishermen's Village. The rest of the year it runs harbor tours, sunset cruises, Peace River trips, and cruises to Cabbage Key, Cayo Costa and Boca Grande. A December evening could be an early table at Latitude 26°, then a canal cruise, then a walk through the Festival of Lights, all without leaving the property.
Getting there without the parking hunt
The Village offers free on-site parking, with more free parking nearby, plus bike parking and boat-and-trailer parking. On festival nights, the Harborwalk is the easier route. It runs about three miles from Laishley Park past Gilchrist Park to the Village. That makes Oct. 17 a good test run, with the Fall Festival at Laishley in the afternoon and a walk west for dinner at the wharf.
Living close to the Harborwalk and the Village shapes everyday life in Punta Gorda more than most listing descriptions let on. If you're deciding how close to the waterfront you want to be, or what your current home is worth this season, Chadwick Knight can help. Request your free home valuation or market consultation, and we'll walk you through the streets between downtown and Fishermen's Village.