Sunlit limestone courtyard beside a cream stucco home with arched loggia, terracotta roof and a single fan palm.

Fifth Avenue South Is Rearranging Itself Before Season. Here's Where the Familiar Names Went

On the north side of Fifth Avenue South, just west of Inn on Fifth, a two-story building has stood gutted since summer 2025. It held L'Olivo and Roma. Restaurateur Feibi Gouda, whose family ran L'Olivo for more than six years, told Naples Press this month that "it looks like war in the building."

That building is the most visible gap on the avenue going into the 2026–27 season. It isn't the only one. Several longtime tenants have left their storefronts this year. Almost all of them are still in business, though, and most are a short walk or a short drive from where they used to be. Most of the empty windows come from one landlord re-leasing its ground floors. If you know where the familiar names went, this season's Fifth Avenue is much easier to use.

One landlord's leasing plan explains most of the empty windows

Fifth Avenue South has been remade before. As Naples Press reported on Oct. 16, the city began the first makeover in 1994 with planners Andrés Duany and Elizabeth Plater-Zyberk. That effort produced Sugden Community Theatre, what is now the Naples Art Institute, and the parking garages. Hoffmann Commercial Real Estate started buying downtown buildings in 2015. In 2023 the company sold some 27 Naples addresses, more than a dozen of them downtown, to Aspen-based M Development.

M Development's Naples property manager, Derek Nagy, described the plan in the same article. He wants to pull retailers back from places like Mercato to Fifth Avenue, where the foot traffic is. "The big push is soft retail, as opposed to office," he said. "We're trying to put a lot of retail on the first floor now." Larger spaces are the main target.

Gallery owner Aldo Castillo told Naples Press that most of the available space on the avenue is held by two landlords, M Development and HF Companies. With that few owners, one company's leasing plan can change several blocks in a single year. That's why this fall's changes arrived together instead of trickling in.

Where the regulars went

Here are this year's moves, with each business's old and new address.

Business Was Now When
Regatta 760 Fifth Ave. S. 8799 U.S. 41 N., The Marketplace at Pelican Bay Reported Oct. 16
Wind in the Willows Corner storefront, 675 Fifth Ave. S. Side-street entrance, same building Reported Oct. 16
Silver Eagle Gallery 850 Fifth Ave. S. 780 Seagate Drive September 2026
Aldo Castillo Gallery 634 Fifth Ave. S. 472 Fifth Ave. S., next to Bar Tulia Nov. 1
East-West Sports Cards & Collectibles 785 Fifth Ave. S. 634 Fifth Ave. S. Following Castillo's move
GLDN Hour Coffee Co. 900 Sixth Ave. S. 863 Fourth Ave. S. Closed July 25, reopened September

A few of these moves need explaining. Regatta, known for one-of-a-kind gifts, had been downtown since 1985. Its new home is on U.S. 41 at Vanderbilt Beach Road, so it's now a short drive north rather than a stroll. Wind in the Willows, the clothier with the porcelain, script-lettered facade, never left its building. It moved its door around the corner.

Silver Eagle Gallery, which sells Native American jewelry and accessories, wasn't in an M Development building. It left Fifth Avenue anyway and moved to Seagate Drive in September, as Natural Awakenings reported.

Castillo's gallery stays on the avenue at 472. The move, set for Nov. 1, opens his old 1,750-square-foot space at 634 for East-West Sports Cards. GLDN Hour's morning coffee moved two blocks north, to Fourth Avenue South. Florida Weekly found the new shop serving takeout only when it visited, so check before planning to sit down.

What is filling the old spaces

The leasing plan shows most clearly in what replaces the departed tenants. M Development split the former Regatta store into two shops, a flip-flop boutique and Spartina 449, a women's clothing brand's own store. The company also brought in Johnnie-O, a casual menswear brand. Faherty, an upscale clothing brand, is set to take the Wind in the Willows corner.

The October reporting describes these four as incoming and doesn't give opening dates. Some may still be dark when you walk by this week.

Smaller local food businesses are opening in the same blocks. Tiny Kitchen Empanadas opened this summer on Park Street, just off Fifth, in the same building as Castillo's old gallery. As Florida Weekly reported, its owners first built a following under the name CDL Empanadas, selling from a trolley and a stand at the Third Street Farmers Market. Park Street is their first brick-and-mortar location. When Naples Press stopped in, records were spinning on a vintage turntable, and beef, chicken, spinach-ricotta, ham-and-cheese and mushroom empanadas were going out at a steady pace, even in mid-afternoon.

Tim Aten's first-half 2026 roundup also lists these as new downtown places to eat:

  • All Too Well Gourmet Sandwiches, on Fifth Avenue South
  • Barrio Taqueria, on Fifth Avenue South
  • Annie's Bistro, inside the new Olde Naples Hotel
  • Tiny Kitchen Empanadas, on Park Street

None of the four is a white-tablecloth room. Together they cover a quick lunch on Fifth better than the avenue did a year ago, while the bigger dining spaces are tied up.

Why the old L'Olivo building is still empty

The 649–663 Fifth Ave. S. building is the biggest of those tied-up spaces. Its delay has nothing to do with the restaurant plan. M Development owns it through an entity called NECO 649-663 5th Avenue South LLC. Construction was supposed to start last December. Interior demolition went ahead under early permits, and then the final building permit stalled.

Naples Press reported that city staff treated the 60-year-old building as new construction because the project counted as substantial redevelopment. That meant meeting the current building code. The city questioned the structural engineer's floodproofing analysis, the developer brought in a geologist for soil borings, and a stormwater review letter dated May 7 asked for the total square footage being rebuilt across the project's permits.

Gouda explained to Naples Press where the hold-up sits:

"For the restaurant, everything has been approved. All the permits for the restaurants have been approved. What has put us behind is the building. It's not because of the restaurant."

The space is set to become Riva Mediterranean Restaurant & Lounge at 651 Fifth Ave. S., with Zanu Sushi Bar next door where Roma pizzeria was. Gouda hoped to have the construction permit by the end of October and expects six to eight months of work once it's issued, which puts the opening after the 2026–27 season. The city's Design Review Board still has to approve facade changes, though interior work can start before that. No tenants have been announced for the second floor.

The operators behind the new names are longtime locals. Gouda and her husband, Raafat Bishai, have run Naples restaurants for 25 years, among them Falafel Grill and, at this same address, South Ave Restaurant and Crispy Seafood & Wine Bar before L'Olivo. Nagy put it in Naples Press's Oct. 16 retail story as L'Olivo "coming back," with several other concepts. Put the two reports together and it's the same family returning to the same address under new names, about a year later than planned.

The fall calendar that brings people to the avenue

Nagy's plan rests on foot traffic. The Fifth Avenue South events calendar supplies much of it between now and the holidays, and the first weeks of it overlap with Castillo's Nov. 1 move to 472.

  1. Oct. 31: Halloween Spooktacular at Cambier Park, 3 to 5 p.m., then Evening on Fifth, 5 to 8 p.m.
  2. Nov. 1: Naples Concert Band at Cambier Park, 2 to 3 p.m. Castillo's gallery opens at 472 Fifth Ave. S. the same day.
  3. Nov. 5: Author events at Books on Third, listed on the Third Street South events page.
  4. Nov. 9: Stardust Memories Big Band at Cambier Park, 7 to 9 p.m.
  5. Nov. 12: Evening on Fifth, 6:30 to 9:30 p.m.
  6. Nov. 15: Naples Big Band at Cambier Park, 2 to 4 p.m.
  7. Dec. 4–5: Christmas Walk and tree lighting on Fifth Avenue South.
  8. Dec. 6 and Dec. 7: Naples Concert Band, then Stardust Memories Big Band, both at Cambier Park.
  9. Dec. 8: Christmas Parade, 6:30 to 8:30 p.m.
  10. Dec. 10: Evening on Fifth, 6:30 to 9:30 p.m.
  11. Dec. 11: Tuba Christmas at Sugden Plaza, 6:30 to 7:30 p.m.
  12. Dec. 19: Christmas Boat Parade on Naples Bay, 6:15 to 8:30 p.m., with ticketed viewing at Naples City Dock.

Families heading to Cambier for the Halloween event should know the playground is still under construction. The city's Sept. 29 update had it in permitting and custom-equipment manufacturing, with completion forecast for July 2027.

Saturday mornings also shift next month. The Third Street South Farmers Market runs 7:30 to 11:30 a.m. and has been set up behind Tommy Bahama from April through October. From November through May it moves onto Third Street South between Broad and 13th Avenue South. The Tiny Kitchen owners built their following at this market as CDL Empanadas, and their Park Street storefront is now a few blocks' walk from it.

If you own on or near Fifth and want to know how this year's re-leasing on the avenue might show up in your home's value, Chadwick Knight can put together a market consultation built around your street. Request your free home valuation or market consultation, and we'll go through it with you before season starts.

Work With Chadwick

Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact me today.

Follow Me on Instagram